z

Young Writers Society



Thoughts

by Jenna Frenzel


A warm summer’s day, a harsh winter night; these things, like all other things we can see, touch, make up the world. Along with these things come all things in a larger scale: planets, nebulae, stars, galaxies, universes. All these things make up something bigger.

But what is that something bigger, a few of the good people in the world might be inclined to ask themselves or perhaps someone else. How come, when all else in the world is still, there is always something moving—atoms, electrons, protons, all moving in their own state of flux.

How, those same people could ask, raising their precious voices to the stars and beyond, can the earth be so contradictory to itself, bending in its own little universe as bubble-headed as those people who don’t care how big the universe is—or alternatively, those who don’t care about anything?

How—? Why—? When—?

These questions, I found out, were the questions I had been sent to answer. The ones I had been made to answer.

No, I was not born in a test tube, as you might think from the previous sentence; I’m a clone, the last one, free-roaming—a runaway experiment, fashioned by the Old Master’s eyes and hands, himself.

Nor was I true-born, like most clones. These true-born were made to serve and were then forced into slavery. I had been created by the Old Master to stop this—to stop the fighting, to bring peace.

The Old Master was victim of his own folly, and just like the people who followed him, were considered insane and thrown in confinement, imprisoned forever.

Everyone always forgot the people in confinement and, just like everyone else, so were they—defeated, they had stormed off to congregate in their own little three by three yard cells to talk about the next big war.

But no one had listened because everyone had forgotten. They were made to forget—the ultimate government cover-up; mind control.

It was fairly common these days, I knew. Being the last true free clone in the world—the last free person—she alone was open minded. She alone knew the truth. And now the earth was in the middle of a planet-wide war, or at least that’s what the government said; the war was more like interplanetary, millions—trillions, even—dead. So many deaths, and yet no one had listened.

The Old Master used to hold power over the government back in the day, as sort of a scientific seer. When he foresaw this war, he cloned volunteers as fast as possible, trying to prepare the masses for revolution against the government, against mind control.

But no one had listened.

They had killed all the free clones and imprisoned more; only I escaped. No one bothered to remember the world as it had been a hundred—maybe even two hundred—years before; lush, green forests and grasslands with tropical fish and birds and other animals now extinct like tigers and polar bears. Now, in the present, if you were to say any of those words at random, in public, no one would know what you would be talking about; it would sound like the long extinct Russian language to them. They had never thought to look them up in an old dictionary—why should they? It was old. Old was disgusting to them, even the imprisoned clones who had been surrounded by these thoughts for far too long.

It was like a disease, slowly spreading through all the human civilizations in all the planets that were inhabited. The Old Master called it cockiness, a strange word so out of date I barely even knew what it had meant at the time.

I was his favorite, and it didn’t surprise me why: I had been made in the appearance of the Old Master’s long-lost and long-dead daughter; light brown hair, full lips, golden-bronze skin, and a bit chubby around the cheeks. But of course all the chubby was gone, now that this war had started and I was older, without the comfort of my dad at my side. I remembered those short nights when I had stayed up the whole time with him, just talking. I couldn’t even remember what we had been talking about, but now that he was gone—forgotten forever behind black curtains of the government’s ignorance—the memory was more precious than ever. And I could never forget, because I was a clone and clones never forget anything—or at least that’s what I told myself. Even now, I could feel the fuzziness of those wonderful days that flashed by so quickly deepening as if submerged in one of the polluted oceans of the day.

How could I possibly forget?

Once I peeled away the fuzziness, the memory was clear as the protein shakes that were clearer than water—those that didn’t bend the light so it looked like you were sipping air when you had it in your cup. And, just like the memory, you could feel the drink on your lips as it flowed, almost willingly into your mouth as if it was alive; if you closed your eyes, just for a second, you could just imagine that the shake was a brilliant, bright crimson, just how it tasted….

But then, no one had listened.

That was the thought that kept me going all these years, and that alone. My actions were fueled by anger, as if I had collected all the peoples’—forgotten along with their memories and free thought—and channeled it into one little peephole inside me, so that it came out in a hard stream, intense and shining, yet soothing and screaming at the same time, like a bucket of cold water thrown over your head after a long days’ work in the hot, summer sun.

I had almost laughed at that the first time I thought of it: work! The only work people got these days is pushing buttons on the TV remote.

Every time I almost get rid of all my anger, I remember how everyone forgot—how they all, a collective mind, left me locked in a closet to die with the promise of the Old Master and my game of hide-and-seek coming to an end soon and that he would come any moment and unlock my door, saying “Found you! Come on, supper’s going to be ready soon”.

But he never came, and I had found myself being carried away, not in the Old Master’s arms, but in some strangers’, being mistaken for the Old Master’s real daughter. Strange men in a familiar house. Confusion; it all speaks for itself.

At this point in my life, I have no clue where it’s going. All I know is that somehow I need to avenge the Forgotten and bring them back home whether they’re alive or not.

No one remembered, and the Old Master—along with my true past—was forgotten.

I sighed; but now to sleep.


Note: You are not logged in, but you can still leave a comment or review. Before it shows up, a moderator will need to approve your comment (this is only a safeguard against spambots). Leave your email if you would like to be notified when your message is approved.







Is this a review?


  

Comments



User avatar
28 Reviews


Points: 3325
Reviews: 28

Donate
Mon Dec 22, 2008 9:44 pm
Suzuhara wrote a review...



A warm summer’s day, a harsh winter night; these things, like all other things we can see, touch, make up the world. Along with these things come all things in a larger scale: planets, nebulae, stars, galaxies, universes. All these things make up something bigger.


But what is that something bigger, a few of the good people in the world might be inclined to ask themselves or perhaps someone else. How come, when all else in the world is still, there is always something moving—atoms, electrons, protons, all moving in their own state of flux.


How, those same people could ask, raising their precious voices to the stars and beyond, can the earth be so contradictory to itself, bending in its own little universe as bubble-headed as those people who don’t care how big the universe is—or alternatively, those who don’t care about anything?


How—? Why—? When—?


These questions, I found out, were the questions I had been sent to answer. The ones I had been made to answer.


No, I was not born in a test tube, as you might think from the previous sentence;


(I suggest you cut all the stuff above and start with the sentence "I'm a clone..." from below. If not, then try reducing your introduction above because it can easily lose the reader's interest. This is just my opinion)


I’m a clone, the last one, free-roaming—a runaway experiment, fashioned by the Old Master’s eyes and hands, himself. (By beginning with this, I'm quickly hooked to your story.)


Nor was I true-born, like most clones. These true-born were made to serve and were then forced into slavery. I had been created by the Old Master to stop this—to stop the fighting, to bring peace.


The Old Master was victim of his own folly, and just like the people who followed him, were considered insane and thrown in confinement, imprisoned forever.


Everyone always forgot the people in confinement and, just like everyone else, so were they—defeated, they had stormed off to congregate in their own little three by three yard cells to talk about the next big war.


But no one had listened because everyone had forgotten. They were made to forget—the ultimate government cover-up; mind control.

(I'm not sure if you want to do all this telling. If this is an idea net, okay, but if this is for readers to read, I suggest you get to the part where the character is living out her life or doing something and then incorporate all the information throughout your prose.)


It was fairly common these days, I knew. Being the last true free clone in the world (I already know she's the last clone. No need to repeat)—the last free person—she alone was open minded. She alone knew the truth. And now the earth was in the middle of a planet-wide war, or at least that’s what the government said; the war was more like interplanetary, millions—trillions, even—dead. So many deaths, and yet no one had listened.


The Old Master used to hold power over the government back in the day, as sort of a scientific seer. When he foresaw this war, he cloned volunteers as fast as possible, trying to prepare the masses for revolution against the government, against mind control.


But no one had listened.


They had killed all the free clones and imprisoned more; only I escaped. No one bothered to remember the world as it had been a hundred—maybe even two hundred—years before; lush, green forests and grasslands with tropical fish and birds and other animals now extinct like tigers and polar bears. Now, in the present, if you were to say any of those words at random, in public, no one would know what you would be talking about; it would sound like the long extinct Russian language to them. They had never thought to look them up in an old dictionary—why should they? It was old. Old was disgusting to them, even the imprisoned clones who had been surrounded by these thoughts for far too long.

It was like a disease, slowly spreading through all the human civilizations in all the planets that were inhabited. The Old Master called it cockiness, a strange word so out of date I barely even knew what it had meant at the time.


I was his favorite, and it didn’t surprise me why: I had been made in the appearance of the Old Master’s long-lost and long-dead daughter; light brown hair, full lips, golden-bronze skin, and a bit chubby around the cheeks. But of course all the chubby was gone, now that this war had started and I was older, without the comfort of my dad at my side. I remembered those short nights when I had stayed up the whole time with him, just talking. I couldn’t even remember what we had been talking about, but now that he was gone—forgotten forever behind black curtains of the government’s ignorance—the memory was more precious than ever. And I could never forget, because I was a clone and clones never forget anything—or at least that’s what I told myself. Even now, I could feel the fuzziness of those wonderful days that flashed by so quickly deepening as if submerged in one of the polluted oceans of the day.


How could I possibly forget?


Once I peeled away the fuzziness, the memory was clear as the protein shakes that were clearer than water—those that didn’t bend the light so it looked like you were sipping air when you had it in your cup. And, just like the memory, you could feel the drink on your lips as it flowed, almost willingly into your mouth as if it was alive; if you closed your eyes, just for a second, you could just imagine that the shake was a brilliant, bright crimson, just how it tasted….


But then, no one had listened.


That was the thought that kept me going all these years, and that alone. My actions were fueled by anger, as if I had collected all the peoples’—forgotten along with their memories and free thought—and channeled it into one little peephole inside me, so that it came out in a hard stream, intense and shining, yet soothing and screaming at the same time, like a bucket of cold water thrown over your head after a long days’ work in the hot, summer sun.


I had almost laughed at that the first time I thought of it: work! The only work people got these days is pushing buttons on the TV remote.


Every time I almost get rid of all my anger, I remember how everyone forgot—how they all, a collective mind, left me locked in a closet to die with the promise of the Old Master and my game of hide-and-seek coming to an end soon and that he would come any moment and unlock my door, saying “Found you! Come on, supper’s going to be ready soon”.


But he never came, and I had found myself being carried away, not in the Old Master’s arms, but in some strangers’, being mistaken for the Old Master’s real daughter. Strange men in a familiar house. Confusion; it all speaks for itself.


At this point in my life, I have no clue where it’s going. All I know is that somehow I need to avenge the Forgotten and bring them back home whether they’re alive or not.


No one remembered, and the Old Master—along with my true past—was forgotten.


I sighed; but now to sleep.



Hi there! I really like the premise of your story, but I'm a bit weary of its execution. I forgot, but is this a short story or the start of the novel? Whether it's one or the other, you are only telling, not showing us how this character lives her life as a clone, what she goes through, how she feels, and so forth. How about making us go through her life. Show it, do not tell. Hope that helps!


Suzu




User avatar


Points: 890
Reviews: 3

Donate
Sat Dec 20, 2008 5:55 am
AaquianNotyou wrote a review...



In all honesty, Miss/Sir, I enjoyed the original post as much as your revision. Yes, I'll agree some parts were confusing, like where you mentioned 'She' in regard to the your character. But... I have to say, that threw me off for a second at the most. Or, maybe I'm just a curious being for taking enjoyment in reading something that can make me think and reread for the assurance that I understand...

Also, you did seem to use quite a few dashes. In terms of aesthetics, it looks nice and certainly replaces the ellipsis quite well, while keeping that sense of pause. Though... I really do not see what's wrong with them. Maybe I'm just too new to this. Ah well, all in all I have to say I enjoyed reading this, and I just might read this piece again for the fun of it. Your style is interesting and definitely favorable, although perhaps some shorter, clearer sentences here or there, no major revamping, would be nice.

Sorry, I'm very new to reviewing... But I really did enjoy this piece. I'm just not sure how to put it. There may be room for improvement, but I can't think of anything that hasn't been posted already. I look forward to seeing a follow-up to this one.




User avatar
6 Reviews


Points: 890
Reviews: 6

Donate
Thu Dec 18, 2008 7:00 pm
Jenna Frenzel says...



Ok guys, how's this:

A warm summer’s day, a harsh winter’s night; these things, like all other objects we can see, touch, make up the world. Along with these items come all things in a larger scale: planets, nebulae, stars, galaxies, universes. All of these components make up something bigger.
“But what is that ‘something bigger?’” a few of the good people in the world might be inclined to ask themselves, or perhaps someone else. How come, when all else in the world is still, there is always something moving—atoms, electrons, protons, all moving in their own little state of flux.
“How,” those same people could ask, raising their precious voices to the stars and beyond, “can the earth be so contradictory to itself, bending in its own little universe as bubble-headed as those people who don’t care how big the universe is? Or alternatively, those who don’t care about anything?”
How—? Why—? When—?
These questions, I found out, were the questions I had been sent to answer. The ones I had been made to answer, and the ones the clones had been born to keep hidden.
No, I was not born in a test tube, as you might think from the previous sentence; I’m a clone, the last one, free-roaming—a runaway experiment, fashioned by the Old Master’s eyes and hands, himself. Nor was I true-born, like most clones. These true-born were made to serve and were then forced into slavery. I had been secretly created by the Old Master to stop this—to stop the fighting, to bring peace.
The Old Master was victim of his own folly, and just like the people who followed him, was considered insane and thrown in confinement, imprisoned forever.
Everyone always forgot the people in confinement and, just like everyone else, the people who supported the Old Master were as well—defeated, they had stormed off to congregate in their own little three by three yard cells to talk about the next big war.
But no one had listened because everyone had forgotten. The people were made to forget. The ultimate government cover-up: mind control.
It was fairly common these days, I knew. Being the last true free clone in the world—the last free person—I alone was open minded. I alone knew the truth. And now the earth was in the middle of a planet-wide war, or at least that’s what the government said; the war was more like interplanetary, millions—trillions, even—dead. So many deaths, and yet no one had listened.
The Old Master used to hold power over the government back in the day, as sort of a scientific seer. When he foresaw this war, he cloned volunteers as fast as possible, trying to prepare the masses for revolution against the government, against mind control.
But no one had listened.
They had killed all the free clones and imprisoned more; only I escaped. No one bothered to remember the world as it had been a hundred—maybe even two hundred—years before; lush, green forests and grasslands with tropical fish and birds and other animals now extinct like tigers and polar bears. Now, in the present, if you were to say any of those words at random, in public, no one would know what you would be talking about; it would sound like the long extinct Russian language to them. They had never thought to look them up in an old dictionary—why should they? It was old. Old was disgusting to them, even the imprisoned clones who had been surrounded by these thoughts for far too long.
It was like a disease, slowly spreading through all the human civilizations in all the planets that were inhabited. The Old Master called it cockiness, a strange word so out of date I barely even knew what it had meant at the time.
I was his favorite, and it didn’t surprise me why: I had been made in the appearance of the Old Master’s long-lost and long-dead daughter; light brown hair, full lips, golden-bronze skin, and a bit chubby around the cheeks. But of course all the chubbiness was gone, now that this war had started and I was older, without the comfort of my dad at my side. I remembered those short nights when I had stayed up the whole time with him, just talking. I couldn’t even remember what we had been talking about, but now that he was gone, forgotten forever behind black curtains of the government’s ignorance, the memory was more precious than ever. And I could never forget, because I was a clone and clones never forget anything. Or at least that’s what I told myself. Even now, I could feel the fuzziness of those wonderful days that flashed by so quickly deepening as if submerged in one of the polluted oceans of the day.
But how could I possibly forget?
Once I peeled away the fuzziness, the memory was clear as the protein shakes that were clearer than water—those that didn’t bend the light so it looked like you were sipping air when you had it in your cup. And, just like the memory, you could feel the drink on your lips as it flowed, almost willingly into your mouth as if it was alive; if you closed your eyes, just for a second, you could just imagine that the shake was a brilliant, bright crimson, just how it tasted….
But then, no one had listened.
That was the thought that kept me going all these years, and that alone. My actions were fueled by anger, as if I had collected all the peoples’—forgotten along with their memories and free thought—and channeled it into one little peephole inside me, so that it came out in a hard stream, intense and shining, yet soothing and screaming at the same time, like a bucket of cold water thrown over your head after a long days’ work in the hot, summer sun.
I had almost laughed at that the first time I thought of it: work! The only work people got these days is pushing buttons on the TV remote.
Every time I almost get rid of all my anger, I remember how everyone forgot; how they all, a collective mind, left me locked in a closet to die with the promise of the Old Master and my game of hide-and-seek coming to an end soon and that he would come any moment and unlock my door, saying “Found you! Come on, supper’s going to be ready soon”.
But he never came, and I had found myself being carried away, not in the Old Master’s arms, but in some strangers’, being mistaken for the Old Master’s real daughter. Strange men in a familiar house…confusion; it all speaks for itself.
At this point in my life, I have no clue where it’s going. All I know is that somehow I need to avenge the Forgotten and bring them back home whether they’re alive or not.
No one remembered, and the Old Master, along with my true past, was forgotten.
All I knew was that I wouldn’t forget. No, I would never, ever forget this.




User avatar
6 Reviews


Points: 890
Reviews: 6

Donate
Thu Dec 18, 2008 6:28 pm
Jenna Frenzel says...



Thank you all for these comments! I hope to revise this, when I find the time....




User avatar
25 Reviews


Points: 1140
Reviews: 25

Donate
Sun Jul 06, 2008 7:02 am
Speele wrote a review...



But what is that something bigger, a few of the good people in the world might be inclined to ask themselves or perhaps someone else.


Long sentence. Too long. It becomes confusing. Some commas and italics on 'is' for emphasis might be helpful. Also that last phrase begs to be a new sentence. Here is a suggested rewrite, though you're obviously free to do as you please and you could probably do a better job than I. Just an idea or suggestion.

"But what is that something bigger," a few of the good people in this world might be inclined to ask themseles. And then to ask another, when they find they don't have the awnser."

How, those same people could ask, raising their precious voices to the stars and beyond, can the earth be so contradictory to itself, bending in its own little universe as bubble-headed as those people who don’t care how big the universe is—or alternatively, those who don’t care about anything?


Whoo! Can anyone say run-on? Spread it out, for clarity's sake. And I'd also use italics or quotation marks on the people's question again here.

It was fairly common these days, I knew. Being the last true free clone in the world—the last free person—she alone was open minded

Either she is some new random person, or you're switching veiws. Neither good things.

These questions, I found out, were the questions I had been sent to answer. The ones I had been made to answer.


It is never clear how thsi person was sent to awnser the question's of the universe. Perhaps it's just because this is an introductory thing, but the statement is confusing and seems to belong in a seperate story.

No, I was not born in a test tube, as you might think from the previous sentence


I thought nothing of the sort. I don't even see why you would think that. Except you said someone made this person, but alot of people beleive they were created. So either give some foreshadowing of this or cut it.

Everyone always forgot the people in confinement and, just like everyone else, so were they—defeated, they had stormed off to congregate in their own little three by three yard cells to talk about the next big war.


Um.... what? Like everyone else, what? I may be being thick-headed but ya know, you want your writing to be accesible to even the likes of me.

course all the chubby was gone


All the chubbiness, instead?


forgotten forever behind black curtains of the government’s ignorance—the memory was more precious than ever.


Beautiful.

Once I peeled away the fuzziness, the memory was clear as the protein shakes that were clearer than water—those that didn’t bend the light so it looked like you were sipping air when you had it in your cup. And, just like the memory, you could feel the drink on your lips as it flowed, almost willingly into your mouth as if it was alive; if you closed your eyes, just for a second, you could just imagine that the shake was a brilliant, bright crimson, just how it tasted….


Also gorgous.

I sighed; but now to sleep.


Well... that was rather anticlimatic. Give it some drama, kick it up a notch! Maybe "But I had not forgotten. I would never forget."

All in all, I liked it. Your main problem was confusion which could usually be solved with shorter and more precise sentences. An easy enough fix. It's a classic idea, with a few wicked twists. Bravo!




User avatar
402 Reviews


Points: 6517
Reviews: 402

Donate
Fri Jul 04, 2008 2:06 am
Clo wrote a review...



A warm summer’s day, a harsh winter night; these things, like all other things we can see, [s]touch[/s], make up the world. Along with these things come all things in a larger scale: planets, nebulae, stars, galaxies, universes. All these things make up something bigger.

1.) You make "summer's" posessive, but not winter? Be consistent: "A harsh winter's night".
2.) Number of times you say "things": Five. Ah! That's four times too many. "Thing" is a very bad word to use in writing anyway.

bending in its own little universe as bubble-headed as those people who don’t care how big the universe is—or alternatively, those who don’t care about anything?

The way this is phrased - is very confusing.

No, I was not born in a test tube, as you might think from the previous sentence; I’m a clone, the last one, free-roaming—a runaway experiment, fashioned by the Old Master’s eyes and hands, himself
.
Everything before this sentence is slightly rambling. You should get to the point much faster. Also, nothing about the previous sentence makes me think "test tube". I think you should mention clones before you bring up that sentence.

Everyone always forgot the people in confinement and, just like everyone else, so were they—defeated, they had stormed off to congregate in their own little three by three yard cells to talk about the next big war

So were they... what? Who is exactly "they" before AND after the dash? The way you have this written is again confusing.

They were made to forget—the ultimate government cover-up; mind control.

The use of this semi-colon is improper. It should be a dash. But, you already use dashes so much. I suggest rephrasing some things and cleaning up some of those dashes.

Being the last true free clone in the world—the last free person—she alone was open minded. She alone knew the truth

Who is this sudden "she"? The main character?


1.) Dash-a-palooza. You use too many dashes. Get rid of a lot of these, they look bad when in abundance.
2.) Wait, what? Some of your sentences are very confusing. I don't always understand the idea you are trying to convey.
3.) You don't explain enough. This goes hand in hand with the confusion. You need to describe more, pump up your paragraphs. For example: who EXACTLY are the "Forgotten"? You never really specify. It's all a blur.

I don't mean to be so harsh, so I hope you don't get discouraged. Of course I want to see this edited and I do want to see more of your work. You can write - you just have some things you need to work on. Don't despair. I'm here for help and support. :D





Memories, left untranslated, can be disowned; memories untranslatable can become someone else’s story.
— YiYun Li